Pub mystery shopping: a four-visit challenge to see if it pays

SYMSaving Tips

Pub mystery shopping means visiting a pub for a mystery shopping company, ordering what the brief tells you, noting service, cleanliness and timings, then writing a report. You are usually refunded for the food or drink set out in the brief and paid a small fee on top, typically a few weeks after your report is approved. It is legitimate work, but legitimate companies never charge you to join.

The catch is that the fee is small and the report takes time. This challenge runs four visits over a month and logs every minute and every pound, so you know whether pub visits are a cheap night out, a small side income or not worth the effort. For the wider picture, including how to find companies, see our guide to mystery shopping in the UK.

How a pub visit works

Each company works slightly differently, but most pub assignments follow the same pattern.

  • You accept a visit through the company's website or app, usually with a date window and a time of day.
  • The brief tells you what to order, how much is refunded and what to observe: greeting, wait at the bar, menu knowledge, toilets, whether you are asked for ID or offered a second drink.
  • You visit as a normal customer, keep your receipt and note times discreetly.
  • You submit a written report, often within 24 hours, sometimes with photos of the outside or the receipt.
  • After the report is checked, the refund and fee are paid, usually by bank transfer or PayPal.

The four-visit challenge

One visit tells you very little. Four gives you an average you can compare with other ways of earning or saving.

  • Week 1: sign up with two or three established companies. Never pay a joining fee. Complete any training quiz.
  • Week 2: do your first visit. Pick one close to home so travel does not hide the real return.
  • Week 3: do two visits, ideally one food visit and one drinks visit, to compare report time.
  • Week 4: do a final visit, then add up your log and work out pay per hour.
  • Throughout: record travel cost, time in the pub, time writing the report, the refund and the fee.

Worked example

The amounts below are illustrative. Fees and refund limits vary by company and assignment, so check each brief.

VisitRefundedFeeTravelYour extra spendHoursNet cash
1. Drinks visit, walking distance£12£8£0£01.5£8
2. Food visit, bus£25£10£4£32.5£3
3. Drinks visit, walking distance£12£8£0£01.25£8
4. Food visit, drove£25£10£5£02.25£5
Total£74£36£9£37.5£24

Net cash is the fee minus travel and anything you bought beyond the brief. £24 for 7.5 hours is £3.20 an hour, well below the minimum wage. But the £74 of food and drink was refunded, so if you would have gone to the pub anyway, those nights cost nothing. That is the honest way to see pub mystery shopping: a way to make a social budget go further, not a job.

Making it pay better

A few habits change the numbers more than chasing extra visits.

  • Take visits you can walk to. Travel was the biggest cost in the example.
  • Stick to the brief. Anything you add yourself is not refunded.
  • Write the report the same evening while details are fresh. It is faster and accepted more often.
  • Group visits: a pub and a nearby shop assignment on the same trip halves the travel per visit.
  • Drop any company that pays late or rejects reports without a clear reason.

Saving the money, not spending it

Because pub visits feel like a night out, it is easy to spend the refund twice. Two simple rules help. First, move the refund and fee into savings as soon as they arrive, since the meal was already paid from your account weeks ago. Second, swap a normal pub night for a mystery shop rather than adding one, so the money you would have spent stays in your budget. SYM, our app, lets you log each payment against a savings goal, so a month of visits becomes a visible amount.

Safety, drinking and driving

A pub brief may ask you to order alcohol. You can usually choose a soft drink option, and you should if you are driving. Never drink and drive to complete a visit, and do not stack several drinks visits in one evening. If a brief asks for something you are uncomfortable with, decline it; good companies have plenty of others.

Tax on mystery shopping fees

Refunds for what you buy are not profit. The fees can count as trading income. The £1,000 trading allowance covers up to £1,000 of gross trading income a tax year from all your side hustles combined, without paying tax or telling HMRC. Above that, you must register for Self Assessment. Our guide to tax on a second income explains how it works, and the 30-day make money challenge shows how to compare mystery shopping with other side hustles.

Your challenge checklist

Tick these off over the month.

  • Signed up with two or three companies that charge no joining fee
  • Log set up: refund, fee, travel, extra spend, hours
  • Four visits completed and reported
  • Every refund and fee moved to savings on arrival
  • Pay per hour worked out at the end of the month
  • Decision made: keep going, keep it as a cheap night out, or stop

Spotting mystery shopping scams

Mystery shopping is a common cover for scams, so check every company before you hand over details. Warning signs include:

  • A fee to join, register or access assignments. Legitimate companies are free.
  • A cheque or transfer sent to you with a request to send part of it back, buy gift cards or move money on. This is a known fraud and can leave you owing the full amount.
  • Unsolicited job offers by text, email or social media message promising high pay for little work.
  • Requests for your bank login details or card PIN. A company only needs your account number and sort code to pay you.
  • Pressure to accept quickly or keep the assignment secret from your bank.
  • If you are unsure, search the company name with the word scam and check its address and contact details. Report fraud to Action Fraud and tell your bank straight away if you have sent money.

Frequently asked questions

Is pub mystery shopping real?
Yes. Pub groups and brewers pay mystery shopping companies to check service and standards, and those companies pay shoppers a fee plus a refund for what the brief tells them to buy.
How much does pub mystery shopping pay?
The fee is usually small and the food or drink in the brief is refunded. Once you count travel and report time, most people earn well below minimum wage, so treat it as a way to make nights out cheaper.
Do I have to drink alcohol?
Usually not. Many briefs allow a soft drink. Never drink and drive to complete a visit.
Do I need to pay to join a mystery shopping company?
No. Legitimate companies are free to join. Asking for a fee is a sign of a scam.
Is mystery shopping income taxable?
Fees can be trading income. The first £1,000 a year of gross trading income from all side hustles is covered by the trading allowance.
  • mystery-shopping
  • pub-mystery-shopping
  • side-hustle
  • saving-challenge
  • extra-income